Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Cynthia Fridlich's avatar

It’s so frustrating. A former professor of mine had a truly wonderful wife; he loved her to distraction. Seeing she had stage 4 terminal cancer, SHE decided what was right for her, her right not to suffer through no end in sight medical treatment that would have, in her mind and ours, just prolonged her and her lover’s suffering.

I have had cancer 3 times. I have a directive not only for my mental health wishes but also how I’d hope to be released from this mostly physical world to a more existentially less stressful, less physical more spiritual reality existing right under nose (grandkid calls the Far Away Land). Are they afraid this might be ((((((((suicide))))))) or “murder,” cue spooky music. I’m not sure. Once in class we were discussing Edna Pontellier’s decision to take leave of the repressive social martyrdom women found themselves thrown into during Victorian era Louisiana.

All but one student (that’d be moi) entertained the idea that while it was a drastic, mostly unnecessary (?) step into freedom for her (broken wing and all), perhaps it was “right” for her. The protests coming out of the mouths of the privileged students around me were loud and annoying. But after class, the discussion continued. The less privileged of us were less vocal and less concerned about the “moral story” that she was fundamentally responsible for her kids and a sinner in the eyes of g-d and more interested in the symbolism embedded in the story. Ya da ya da ya da!

Loved that you posted this today. It gave me much food for thought to gobble up. Right on.

Expand full comment
Lola's avatar

I’m over here hollering “AMEN!” in a large outside voice.

Expand full comment
17 more comments...

No posts